Backpackfor Skool

Patreon vs Substack: Which Is Better for Paid Members?

Patreon vs Substack on fees, payouts, what members get and who each one suits, plus when a paid community fits better. Checked on both sites.

Nathan FieldNathan FieldFounder, Backpack10 min read
ComparisonsPatreon vs Substack

Patreon vs Substack mostly comes down to what you make: Substack is built for writers who want paying email subscribers, and Patreon is built for creators who post video, audio, art and podcasts to paying members. Both take 10% of what members pay, plus card fees. The real differences are in payouts, sales tax and what a paying member actually gets. Every fee here comes from patreon.com and substack.com, checked on 16 November 2026.

Pick Substack if your paid product is writing sent by email, and Patreon if it is video, audio, art or a podcast. Both take 10% of each payment. Patreon adds card fees and a payout fee and handles most sales tax. Substack adds Stripe's card and billing fees, and takes over sales tax from 1 December 2026.

We run our own Skool community, so we look at both from the side of someone deciding where paying members should live. Neither one is a community or course platform, and that matters if you plan to teach. If a paid group with courses is closer to what you want, you can try Skool free for 14 days (affiliate link). We cover where it fits, and where it does not, near the end.

What is the difference between Patreon and Substack?

Substack is a publishing platform. You write posts, they go out by email and into the Substack app, and you choose which posts are free and which are only for paying subscribers. Patreon is a membership platform. You set up tiers, post to members, and sell one-time items, with video, audio and podcasts treated as first-class content.

The money also moves differently. On Substack you click "Connect with Stripe" and payments land in your own Stripe account. On Patreon, Patreon's help centre says "Patreon = Merchant": it runs the checkout, deals with chargebacks and pays you out from your Patreon balance.

SubstackPatreon
Built forNewsletters, plus podcasts and live videoMemberships with video, audio, art and podcasts
Cost to startFreeFree
Platform fee10% of each subscription payment10% (pages published after 4 Aug 2025)
Who takes the paymentYour own Stripe accountPatreon, as the merchant
Paid plansMonthly, yearly and a founding member planMonthly and annual tiers, plus one-time purchases
Members talk inChat (up to 16 chats)Chats (up to 10 chat spaces), DMs, comments, Discord sync

How much do Patreon and Substack take from each payment?

Both take 10% as a platform fee, and both charge 2.9% + $0.30 on a US card payment. Substack adds Stripe's 0.7% Billing fee on recurring payments. Patreon adds a small fee each time you pay out. The figures below are from Patreon's pricing page, Patreon's creator fees overview and Substack's How much does Substack cost? article, all read on 16 November 2026.

FeePatreon (standard plan)Substack
Platform fee10%, worked out before sales tax10% of each subscription payment
US card processing2.9% + $0.30 (cards and Apple Pay, any location)2.9% + $0.30 per payment (Stripe)
Recurring billing feeNone listed0.7% (Stripe Billing)
PayPal or Venmo2.9% + $0.30 in the US, 3.9% + $0.30 outside itNot in Substack's list of payment methods
Currency conversion2.5% when a member pays in a different currency from your payout currencyNot listed on Substack's cost page
Payout fee$0.25 per US bank payout; PayPal 1% (minimum $0.25, capped at $20)None listed by Substack
Custom domainAvailable on the new creator page, no fee listed$50, one time
iPhone app purchasesApple's 30% fee; Patreon waives its processing fee but keeps its 10%Apple's fee; Substack's 10% is based on your web price

One catch on Patreon: the 10% is for creator pages published after 4 August 2025. Pages published on or before that date keep their older plan (5%, 8% or 11%) only while they stay published. Patreon says unpublishing, even briefly, moves you to the 10% plan when you come back.

What does that look like on 100 members?

Say 100 members each pay $10 a month, all on US cards, billed monthly, paid out in US dollars, with no tax added. This is our own maths from the rates above.

  • Patreon: $100 platform fee plus $59 processing (100 x 2.9% of $10, plus 100 x $0.30) = $159. You keep $841, less $0.25 for each bank payout.
  • Substack: $100 platform fee plus $59 card fees plus $7 Billing fee = $166. You keep $834.

Small prices hurt more on both. Substack's lowest monthly price is $5 for US-dollar Stripe accounts. On a $5 payment, Patreon's fees come to about $0.95 and Substack's to about $0.98, because the flat $0.30 is a big slice of a small price.

On a $5 plan, close to a fifth of every payment goes in fees on either platform.

Who handles sales tax and VAT on Patreon and Substack?

Patreon handles it today, and Substack starts handling it on 1 December 2026. Patreon's pricing page says "We take care of most applicable tax collections and remittance for you." Its VAT article says it calculates and collects VAT where it has to, then files and pays it. Patreon still suggests a local tax adviser to confirm what you owe yourself.

On Substack, writers have held that job until now: registering, setting rates and filing, with Stripe Tax as an optional helper. Substack's article on upcoming changes to tax says that from 1 December 2026 it "calculates, collects, and remits sales tax or VAT" on paid subscriptions at no extra cost. It switches on by itself for every publication with payments on. The exception: publishers in Brazil, Mexico, Malaysia, India and Thailand stay responsible for their own tax.

This is how each platform describes its own setup, not tax advice. Check your own position with a tax adviser.

How do payouts work on each?

Substack pays out faster. Patreon holds your money in a balance until you withdraw it.

Patreon

Patreon's payouts article says your share lands in your creator balance after fees. You can withdraw all or part of it by hand, once every 24 hours, or turn on an automatic payout on the 5th of each month. Deposits "typically arrive within 10 days". A few holds to know about:

  • Adding or editing a payout method puts a 5-day lock on your balance.
  • One-time purchases made on the web or Android sit as pending for up to 7 days.
  • Anything bought through Apple's in-app purchase on iPhone stays pending for up to 75 days.
  • PayPal payouts need at least $10 in the balance.

Substack

Substack's payouts article says payments "usually arrive in your bank account within 48 hours of each transaction", through your Stripe account. The slow lane is the iPhone app: Apple pays Substack a month at a time, up to 45 days after that month ends, so January's App Store subscriptions show up around mid-March.

What do paying members get on each?

On Substack, paying members mostly get writing. Patreon gives them more kinds of media in one place.

Substack paid subscribers get:

  • Paid-only posts by email and in the Substack app.
  • Paid chats. A publication can run up to 16 chats, and each one can be locked to paid subscribers or founding members.
  • Founding member posts, for readers who pay more than your yearly price.
  • Paid podcast feeds and live video, which Substack now offers from its app.

Patreon members get:

  • Posts with audio, images and rich text, in tiers you set.
  • Native video and livestreaming, with up to 100 hours of video a month while you have paying fans.
  • Up to 10 chat spaces, each one open to all members, paying members or chosen tiers.
  • Discord roles synced to their tier, if you run a Discord server.
  • Digital products and posts to buy one at a time, on top of a membership.

Both let members find you inside the platform: Substack through Notes and its app, Patreon through what it calls "creator-first discovery". Both also let you keep your list: Patreon lists "exportable email lists", and Substack says you "own all of your content and your subscriber list".

Which is better for writers, and which for video, audio and art?

For writers, Substack is the better fit. Email is the product, free and paid posts sit side by side, and money reaches your bank in about two days. The founding member plan also gives your biggest fans a way to pay more.

For video, audio and art, Patreon is the better fit. Video hosting and livestreaming are built in, podcasts can be imported and synced with Spotify or shared by RSS, and members can pay by PayPal or Venmo as well as by card. Patreon also takes chargebacks and most tax off your plate, which matters more when you have many small members in many countries.

Podcasters can go either way. Substack hosts podcasts for free and lets you run paid feeds, while Patreon lists more podcast tools on its pricing page. Pick by whether your listeners came for the writing or for the audio.

What if you want a community or courses instead?

Then neither one is the right tool. Neither Patreon's pricing page nor Substack's cost page lists a course builder, and both treat community as chat next to the content. If you plan to teach a course, run group calls, or want members talking to each other every day, look at a community platform. Our guide to online community platforms compares the main ones, and membership site platforms covers tools that put a paywall on your own website.

Skool is one of those options. Each group gets a community feed, a Classroom for courses, points and levels from likes, a leaderboard, and live calls. Its pricing page lists two plans with unlimited members on both:

  • Hobby: $9 a month, plus 10% + 30c per payment.
  • Pro: $99 a month, plus 2.9% + 30c per payment up to $899.

Card processing is included in those fees, and Skool's payments FAQ says Skool is a "merchant of record" that handles sales tax collection, filing and payment. On the same 100 members at $10, our maths gives $139 in total costs on Hobby and $158 on Pro. Skool pays out every Wednesday. For a closer look at the Patreon side, see Skool vs Patreon, and for more options beyond these two, our list of Patreon alternatives.

When is Skool the wrong pick?

Skool is the wrong pick more often than a Skool affiliate might admit. Choose something else if:

  • Your paid product is a newsletter. Skool is built around a community feed and courses, not a publication that readers subscribe to. Go with Substack.
  • Your members want to pay in their own currency. Skool's FAQ says all prices are in US dollars and members pay in US dollars. Patreon supports 16+ currencies.
  • You want no monthly bill at all. Patreon and Substack are free until you earn. Skool starts at $9 a month.
  • Your audience lives in Discord or in podcast apps. Patreon's Discord role sync and podcast feeds suit that better.

So, Patreon vs Substack: Substack for writing, Patreon for video, audio and art, and neither if you want to run a real community with courses. If that last one sounds like you, you can start a Skool community here (affiliate link), with a 14-day free trial.

FAQ

Is Substack cheaper than Patreon?

Not really. Both take 10% and charge 2.9% + $0.30 on US card payments. Substack adds Stripe's 0.7% Billing fee on recurring payments, while Patreon adds $0.25 per US bank payout. On 100 members paying $10 a month, that is about $166 in fees on Substack and $159 on Patreon.

Does Patreon or Substack handle sales tax?

Patreon does today. It acts as the merchant and says it takes care of most tax collection and remittance. Substack starts on 1 December 2026, when it will calculate, collect and remit sales tax or VAT for most publishers, except those based in Brazil, Mexico, Malaysia, India and Thailand.

How fast do you get paid on Patreon and Substack?

Substack is faster. Its help centre says payments usually reach your bank within 48 hours, through your Stripe account. Patreon keeps your earnings in a balance that you withdraw by hand or automatically on the 5th of each month, and says deposits typically arrive within 10 days.

Are Patreon and Substack free to start?

Yes. Publishing on Substack is free, and Patreon says it is free to start and you only pay when you earn. Both take their 10% only when members pay you, plus payment processing. Substack's lowest paid price is $5 a month or $30 a year for US-dollar Stripe accounts.

Can you take your subscribers with you if you leave?

Both say yes to the email list. Patreon's pricing page lists exportable email lists, and Substack says you own your content and your subscriber list. Paid billing is different: on Substack the subscriptions sit in your own Stripe account, while on Patreon they sit with Patreon as the merchant.

We may earn a commission if you start a Skool community through a link on this page. It costs you nothing extra, and it does not change what we write.

Start on Skool

Start your Skool community today.

Try Skool free for 14 days, then from $9 a month.

Affiliate link: we may earn a commission. It costs you nothing extra.

Start a Skool community14 days free. Affiliate link.
Try free